Don’t Forget….

For now, the green algae on the Saint Lucie has subsided. On the stretch of river that I live on, the birds have returned. I have noticed more mullet jumping out of the water. So I guess things are returning to normal. But what is normal for the Saint Lucie?

Is normal now the cycle we went through this summer? Is it releases of water from Lake Okeechobee that kill oysters and sea grass, turn the water green and keep tourists and locals in fear of being in contact with it? Will the cycle repeat itself as it has in 2014 and 2016, or will it happen every year?

Our Washington representatives have gone away. Their caring faces, fact finding tours and photo ops duly noted. News crews have departed for the next story of disaster. Even our local paper has moved on to the next headline.

Once our state legislative session has begun, will Joe Negron’s bill to buy land south of the lake move forward, or will it die in the morass of Tallahassee? Even if it passes in some form, it requires federal dollars also. We know Washington hasn’t even made good on the dollars to help Florida that it has already pledged.

What I have learned, though, is that we need to keep on plugging away. I am not about to let Washington and Tallahassee forget about us. It would be great if the news media continued to take interest in this story. It would be marvelous if everyone came together and continued the fight. We do not need vitriol and accusations.

There is not just one solution to our problem. Every project that brings us closer to where Florida needs to be should be welcomed. The Saint Lucie, Indian River Lagoon, Lake Okeechobee and the Everglades will require many steps before we can all say the work is complete. We need to keep the pressure on and not despair. It took 100 years for this travesty to reach this level. I am hopeful it won’t take a century to be reversed.

Today’s River Report

I was on a local radio panel with Stephen Leighton, whose company, Oceansphere Technologies, had just cleaned Central Marine of its toxic algae. It was such a thorough job that it went from a 1000 times greater than what the World Health Organization finds acceptable to clean enough for Stephen and his crew to be swimming in the marina water. That was fantastic because the marina could re-open for business and people could go back to work.

While this technology has remediated Central Marine’s problem for now, if something is not done on a macro level, our problems will only continue and get worse. Depending to whom you speak on this subject, the answers will be different and to a lay person like myself confusing. Here is what I do understand…Florida’s watershed evolved in a certain way. We came along and disrupted Mother Nature. The only way it will be fixed is to imitate the original as closely as possible.

By doing so will there be disruptions to our economy and level of growth? Absolutely there will be. The Feds, State and local governments will have to be part of the solution. That will mean we will all have to adapt the way we live. Agricultural practices will need to change. Some of the interior of Florida will have to revert to its original state. Development will need to be curtailed in certain areas. Lake Okeechobee was never meant to be a reservoir. Our highways such as I-75 and the Tamiami Trail will need to be elevated to allow water to flow south.

The over abundant use of fertilizer has to stop not only on our lawns but on our golf courses and farms throughout the state. We should continue with bringing in new sewer systems and making people hook up to them once available. For those that can’t afford to pay all at once, the Federal and State governments should offer loans and grants to do so. From the Panhandle to the Keys, we need to stop pointing fingers and work together.

There are no magic bullets and simple solutions or can we ignore the obvious. We have severe problems. We need to stop using the phrase “lost summer” as if this were a temporary problem when it is not. Stuart and Martin County are harbingers of what will occur throughout Florida unless we stop the political shenanigans and crony capitalism. This is a man-made problem caused by good and bad intentions, short sightedness and sometimes pure greed. We are responsible.

On the river in back of my home empty bottles and other debris are in the water amongst the rocks along the shore. I haven’t cleaned it for a while. I have been afraid. This week like last there is no green algae on the river. It is black and dark without much evidence of marine life. How long do we allow this condition to continue?

The River Isn’t Green This Week

Another week has passed. The attention that Stuart and Martin County have received from the national news media because of the algae has been incredible. Special reports, columns, cameramen and opinions have been broadcast, written and opined. But are we any closer to a solution? I am pessimistically sure that we are not.

What has fundamentally changed? Did we suddenly buy the land to our south? Have the Feds allocated the money to complete the projects that are already on the books? I fear not. Did agricultural subsidies and supports go away? Was there financial campaign reform? Has the Governor finally seen the ecological light? Has the President issued a Declaration? Sorry to report…none of the above.

This failure to correct our problem was not from a lack of trying by our local elected leaders on the Treasure Coast. But we are barely 3% of the state’s population…insignificant to the power brokers of Tallahassee and Washington. President Obama loves playing golf here but hasn’t mentioned our plight even once. If you write him a letter, you get a form one back that doesn’t even mention the reason you wrote, which is a feat of shear political magic.

Will it ever change? Maybe there is just a ray of hope. A reason we can be optimistic. We, the people, are just fed up with the status quo. We are tired of being ignored or being condescended to. Our communities are being ruined in the name of corporate and political greed. We are now the disciples of Howard Beale from the movie, Network that shouted, “We are mad as hell and we are not going to take it anymore!”

We have been treated to technology that cleans and polishes the water so that the algae either is or appears to be gone. Some elected officials and citizens are headed to Washington as they did in the now not-so-bad lost summer of 2014. But I still hear the Republicans shouting at the Democrats and Florida blaming the Feds and the inverse in all of the above. Each of these people will tell you that they are not to blame in “political-speak”…that it is really the other guy.

This week, the river isn’t green in back of my house. This week, the water is just not alive. This week, it is black, mucky, and loaded with bacteria. Is that an improvement? I don’t really know.

The Green River

Who would have thought such a diverse estuary would be dying? I always believed we lived in a country with laws to protect this from happening. Perhaps we do until the polluter is one of the largest sources of contributions to local, state and federal politicians. It is as if no environmental laws exist. He who pays calls the shots I guess.

Florida pols are blaming the Feds and the Feds are blaming Florida. I thought you guys all worked for the people? Our Senators and Congresspersons do their dog and pony show. They take a ride on the river and see the lagoon, have a news conference, then poof they’re gone. The Governor can’t even bother doing that. At least our Florida state legislators come and take the heat but to what end?

From my dock I notice there is not even a bird, which means no fish. It does not matter whether algae is in the water or not, the oysters and fish are gone because of the salinity. The segments of our economy based on tourism and the marine industry are on the verge of collapse. Why do we put up with it? Is it that our political system is so broken that things such as this are allowed to occur?

Or maybe it runs deeper. Perhaps we have abandoned principles and morality for the expedient and greed. Is our system so broken that this is the outcome? Is doing the right thing to be impeded by ideology and the pursuit of self-aggrandizement?

As a small town elected official, l speak to those in Washington and Tallahassee. They give me the same looks and nods that my parents did when I was a kid…”you don’t understand.” Our local commissions and boards pass resolutions that express the will of the people, but the will of the powerful still prevails.

Maybe it is they that do not understand. We have had enough. Our frustrations with the water can no longer sustain business as usual. We don’t care about who gives money to whom. We don’t even care whether sugar or agriculture is good for the economy or not. We know that the quality of the water is not good for us.

The river runs green past my house. It flows to the ocean closing the beaches and killing everything in its wake. The question is as citizens do we buy into the same old routines and patterns. It’s the Democrats! It’s the Republicans! It’s the State! It’s the Federal Government! How about everyone stop blaming the other and just fix the problem. I want the river to stop being green by everyone’s house.

Stuart Lawsuits Won’t Clean Our River

I live on the Saint Lucie River in Stuart. I see the devastation that the release of water from Lake Okeechobee brings literally to my backyard. I hate it! As a Stuart City Commissioner, I lobby our representatives in Tallahassee and Washington to clean up the mess that is the Saint Lucie River and the Indian River Lagoon.

In the Stuart News, a guest column appeared by Mac Stuckey, a Martin County resident. He demands that the City of Stuart hire an environmental attorney and staff to file complaints, make noise and I presume to commence lawsuits against Florida, Washington and anyone else that has some blame. He mentions that we would do so because of Stuart’s police powers to pass ordinances for the welfare of our citizens. Under that authority, the city has passed ordinances to limit the use of septic systems and fertilizer. Mr. Stuckey states that this will not even make a dent. He is largely correct. I agree with him because the Indian River Lagoon and the St. Lucie River comprises hundreds of miles of shore line, and Stuart only has approximately 2 miles bordering these waterways.

On the Treasure Coast alone, there are 13 municipalities and 4 counties which border the Lagoon, River and Lake. The Lagoon itself is a much larger area including, but not limited to, Volusia and Brevard counties, and I don’t know how many cities and towns. What I don’t understand is why Mr. Stuckey believes that Stuart, with 16,000 residents, should spend $500,000 of our taxpayers’ dollars to hire staff to commence law suits, etc., when the problem is much bigger than just our one small community.

Stuart is proud of its environmental record such as completing our 15 year BMAP in the first year. Just last week, the commission passed a resolution supporting a compact formed by the League of Treasure Coast Cities, The League of Sun Coast Cities and League of Space Coast Cities to lobby for these very things mentioned by Mr. Stuckey in Tallahassee and Washington. We also support Martin County’s (Stuart is part of the county and our residents pay county taxes) participation and leadership in the Indian River Lagoon Council.

The tactics that the article promotes will not accomplish anything except be a burden to Stuart’s taxpayers. It is much more practical to work with organizations like the River Coalition, which meets in Stuart’s chamber, to achieve progress. Not being an attorney, my first reaction is not to begin expensive and fruitless litigation. I prefer working with other governmental entities and private groups to further a solution.

The people can vote against their current state and federal representatives in the upcoming elections if they are not satisfied with their performance in this matter. This problem did not occur overnight and will not be solved in a day. A constant amount of political pressure must be applied at all levels of government to achieve those goals outlined in Mr. Stuckey’s guest editorial. While Lake Okeechobee releases are a significant problem for Stuart, litigating with the United States and Florida governments would only lead to tax hikes for our residents and businesses.

Since 1956 the year that Mr. Stuckey came here, Stuart has not grown much in population or land mass as compared to other cities on the Treasure Coast. The City of Port Saint Lucie, which today is the 9th largest city in Florida with over 170,000 in population, did not exist. Fort Pierce is on the Indian River Lagoon and has three times our population. The City of Stuart’s median income is $24,000. What Mr. Stuckey proposes would be close to spending 5% of our entire budget.

This problem needs to be tackled as a region…a state…and a nation. I believe the political process would be more successful than litigation. We need to express ourselves through the ballot box not the courthouse. The voters give the elected representatives the power not the special interests. Let us stop thinking in terms of party affiliation instead of governing philosophies. More of us need to become involved in government and civic organizations. Participation and lobbying of our governments in Tallahassee and Washington would be much more productive.

Here We Are Once Again

“Here” we are once again. This year a little earlier than usual we have arrived “here”. We are in a place where we really do not need to be though all the same “here”.  How often can we be “here” without destroying our way of life and the why we live in Martin County? The killing of our estuary seems to be as inevitable as the water flowing to the ocean via the St. Lucie. So we find ourselves once more in this predicament.

Washington and Tallahassee keep promising to do something. The governor wants the Corp to stop the discharges from Lake Okeechobee into the Caloosahatchee and the St. Lucie. But the governor has done nothing more but paid lip service to our plight. He is not a serious man when it comes to this “problem”. I wrote President Obama three years ago about our river and six months later received a form letter back siting his accomplishments on protecting the environment throughout the country but no acknowledgement of the Indian River Lagoon’s impending death. He is not a serious man when it comes to this “problem”.

Senator Rubio held a press conference here in Stuart. He sat in our city commission chamber and listened to the experts. He promised to fight to end these discharges. The senator was going to come back and report bi-monthly. I guess becoming president became more important. He is not a serious man when it comes to this “problem”.

Representative Harrell and Senator Negron have modestly proposed measures that may bring some relief to the “problem”. Will it be enough help to prevent the death of the rivers and estuaries remains to be seen? We, the people of Florida, did our part; we passed a constitutional amendment to spend money on this “problem”. Unfortunately the powers that be in Tallahassee would rather use the funds for other things and ignore the will of the people. Citizens are only an impediment to the pols getting what they want.

Every year the beauty that is Stuart and Martin County becomes a little less so. Another reason that we are living in this place is gone. The concentration of political power in both Tallahassee and Washington allows for the flaunting of the people’s will. Are we mad enough to really do anything about it? Or will our anger revert to type and once again be manipulated by party hacks and labels. We, the voters, do the same thing over and over and somehow expect a different outcome. In the meantime “here” we are once again.

 

Nothing Is Perfect

Each of us believes we have the answers to the problems besetting our county, state and nation. We are convinced that the other person’s ideas are not only wrong but dangerous. Some impugn the character and motives of people whose solutions disagree with their own. If an alternative solution contradicts their ideas, a few would rather see nothing done.

This denigration of motive and character of those with whom we disagree leads to paralysis in solving the problems that confront us. A good example of this is the problems affecting Florida’s waterways. From our natural springs to the Indian River Lagoon to the Everglades, there are no easy, quick or inexpensive answers. What we cannot afford is to continue a war among us which results in nothing being accomplished.

I would love to have the Kissimmee go back to what it once was. Imagine how pure the water would be if the ranches and farms along its banks would return to savannahs and the towns and cities would all disappear. Lake Okeechobee’s wall could come down, the canals disappear and the area south be returned to swamp instead of developments, farms and sugarcane. Do I really have an expectation that this dream will come true…sorry to say, the answer is no. That leaves two alternatives which is doing nothing short of achieving 100% of one’s own solution or working with others to have more modest yet realistic outcomes achieved.

To me it doesn’t mean we stop advocating and working toward restoring the natural flow to our waterways. In the interim we need to use any means necessary to prevent further denigration of those waterways. An example is the Caulkins’ Water Farm off the C-44 canal. Having seen the farm first hand, I now understand better the negatives and positives to moving forward with this use. The farm is on the canal and has the pumps and gates to allow the water to flow to the farm immediately. Their research shows that its 3200 acres can hold about 45% of the excess water in the C-44 from Lake Okeechobee releases. It would prevent that water from contaminating the Saint Lucie River and Indian River Lagoon.

The water farm is not the final solution to this problem. It is a stop gap measure in the fight to save our waterways. An ultimate grand plan will only be achieved if we accept small steps in going forward. Let’s press on with the goal of moving the water south. The way to do so is by not making more enemies but by making and converting more people into friends for our cause.

I Live On The South Fork

I live on the South Fork of the St. Lucie River. The river is my backyard with the shore of Palm City in the distance. My backyard view includes the mooring field of Stuart. I often hear the people who live on their boats playing music or just speaking to each other. Funny…people don’t seem to understand how sound carries over water depending on wind and other weather variables. And, I need never go to Sailor’s Return to hear their bad bands playing because my back porch has excellent acoustics especially for amplified bass. I often say to Polly, my wife, that if I hear another lousy rendition of “Proud Mary,” I am going to commit suicide.

The old and the new Roosevelt Bridges and the infamous railroad trestle spanning the river are also part of the scene. Sometimes, I think I am in New England with the tall masts of sailing ships anchored right behind my yard. I enjoy the ospreys that perch in the masts of ships and tops of trees waiting for the right moment to swoop down catch a fish in their talons and then often eat that fish while sitting on one my pilings. There are cranes and turns, pelicans and storks. Once, Polly saw a Great Blue Heron catch a rat in the rocks that line the beach and swallow it whole, seeing it go down its long neck.

Dolphin families swim by and jump in and out of the water. Mullet, snook and other fish silently lurk beneath the surface and sometimes splash out of the water. There used to be an old catfish that lived at the end of our dock. I would always point visitors out there and they would inevitably catch the old man and then release him back for the next visitor to do the same.

That catfish is gone now as are the mullet sailing into the air. There are many fewer dolphins. There are less ospreys and other birds. But the water still flows depending on the tide either out to the ocean or toward Lake Okeechobee. It is just stiller now, less vibrant, with more sediment in the water, muck on the bottom and less life.

I often try to picture what the river was like before me. My neighbor, who has lived here for decades, tells me that the river was clear and you could see the bottom when he first moved to his house. Even when I first saw the river from my mother-in-law’s condo, which was a few doors from my current home, I remember the waters clearer. But was it really? For as Proust wrote: “Remembrance of things past is not necessarily the remembrance of things as they were.”

What was the river to the settlers of the late 19th and early 20th centuries? I am told that where my house now stands was part of a pineapple plantation. The river was both a highway and supermarket. Oyster and crabs were plentiful as were all variety of fish. Deer, bear, beaver and otter made their homes on the bank, as did panthers and bobcats. Mother Nature provided a bountiful treasure that man, of course, ravenously did its best to eliminate.

Native Americans lived on the banks of our river and lagoon for thousands of years and still managed to bequeath to us a wonderful and diverse eco system. Those earliest of settlers made peace with the harmony of the waters treating them as sacred and holy…reverence and wonder.  They knew the larder would remain inexhaustible if the balance was maintained. It lasted at least a millenium until us.

For we, as Americans, believed we could bend the will of God while praising His name. My South Fork was not so much a river as part of an estuary. Whatever fresh water that flowed into the river was only runoff from the savannahs along its banks. Since there was no farming, there was no fertilizer to raise the phosphorous and nitrogen levels. The river could remain in its natural brackish state. The fresh mixing with the salt waters as the tides ebbed and flowed was what gave life to the Indian River Lagoon.

But, not being content with the perfect, we thought it better to build the Okeechobee Waterway known affectionately as the C-44 Canal. We added the C-24 and C-23 drainage canals to create farm and pasture instead of savannah and swamp. It was the end of God and the beginning of Mammon. Paradise was being lost for the unsustainable changing of our ecology.

At first we believed that draining and stopping the natural flow of our waterways would give us lush farmland and kill the mosquitos. We built towns in places that Native Americans never lived for they knew better. Crops were planted in soil believed to be lush until the water stopped flowing. We needed to keep all the new western settlements safe from flood so a dyke was built around the lake to prevent the natural flow south of the water.

We decided to connect the lake to the St. Lucie to further a navigational passage to the west. Now there was no problem in sending billions of gallons of fresh water rich in phosphorous and nitrogen from farms and septic tanks down past where my house stands. The fish, animals and plants (not to mention we, the residents,) are not as important to the politicians in Tallahassee or Washington as are the sugar barons around a lake that was made into a reservoir.

The Saint Lucie is fighting for survival. We attack at the edges and pray for deliverance from our sins. We use jargon cloaked in abbreviations such as CERP and BAMP to mask how utterly powerless we are. Green algae are on our shores and yet the obvious solution is locked away. The key is held by the subsidized rich and their sycophantic elected cronies in our state and national capitals.

I have always lived by a body of water. The East River or the Hudson River has been just down the block from where any of my apartments have been in New York City. I owned a country house on the banks of the Delaware River. Long Island Sound was at the end of my street in Connecticut where I lived for a decade. When I first saw the Saint Lucie, I knew I would live here one day.

The river still flows past my house. It is calming and seemingly beautiful in its majesty. I imagine that if and when the water continues to flow in a hundred years, it will seem on the surface much the same. However, will it bring the seeds of a future bountiful life or the barren silhouette of what was in the past? We have it in our power to save the river and the lagoon. 75% of the voters have said yes to our salvation. It is only the few in Tallahassee doing the bidding of the greedy that prevent it from actually happening.

How Far We Have Come From The Founders

Some days, I wake up and I am optimistic about the future. This is not one of those days. Today, I worry about the continued steady march of All Aboard Florida and the degradation of our lagoon. It seems the deck is stacked against the citizens and residents of the Treasure Coast. Our elected representatives in both Washington and Tallahassee pay lip service to our environment and quality of life but then sell us out for a campaign contribution from Big Sugar or AAF or anyone looking to get their subsidized corporate welfare payment.

Hamilton, Jefferson and Madison never envisioned a system where government dollars would be spent subsidizing agriculture or industry.  Alexander Hamilton never asked that the Bank of New York or the New York Post, both of which he founded, be given a subsidy. Thomas Jefferson and James Madison never encouraged the passing of farm bills so they would be paid by the Feds to grow or not grow tobacco.

Our founders were men looking to limit government influence on daily life not encourage more. They had just fought a war to get the British off their backs. It was obvious to them that monopolies and crony capitalism were bad. Government was to be an even arbiter for business and citizens not the deciding factor of who should get tax payer dollars.

But now we see the harm that Big Sugar and AAF are doing and will continue to do is only made possible by our elected representatives. The land south of Okeechobee would be useless if sugar and other agricultural products weren’t subsidized. The private market won’t finance AAF. That is why both Washington and Tallahassee are using public dollars, our taxes, to allow something the people do not want.

The Pols tell you that it is about jobs and affordable food, but the U.S. sugar price is double that of the rest of the world and nothing AAF is doing even remotely resembles high speed passenger rail. More and more, the system favors the well connected and well-off over the rest of us. The people are ignored and deceived so that the gravy train can continue.

It is wrong and we must hold the elected representatives responsible for their actions. We need to stop arguing as if the blather on Fox or MSNBC amounts to anything more than amusement. Whether one is a Republican or Democrat is meaningless in the government today. It is a convenient way to divide us so that the powerful can continue taking more and more and giving less and less. There is no right or left…only the connected and then the rest of us.

We need to wake up and think about actualities not the spurious arguments being made by the news media. When was the last time giving billions in tax breaks and handouts to a sports team resulted in a dollar in your pocket? Since we are giving payments and subsidies to “Big Agriculture,” how come the cost of food is so high? Government’s role is to be the arbiter and make sure the field is level for everyone. They should not choose which business receives the people’s largess.

Amendment 1 was passed by 75% of the voters. Those voters assumed that they were doing so to make sure the sugar land and other strategic parcels were purchased. They didn’t vote for that amendment to fund government agencies or as a big give away to the friends of the governor and legislators. Either the Pols in Tallahassee respect our wishes, or we should vote them out. This is not a Republican or Democrat issue. Because when our rivers are dead and our treasury is dry, no one will care if a liberal or a conservative philosophy resulted in this coming to pass.

Northpoint Through The Prism Of Past, Present & Future

Some at City Hall want to rent a spit of land known as Northpoint to a developer to build a hotel and restaurant. The location of the property is just on the north side of the old Roosevelt Bridge between Dixie Highway, the FEC track and rail road bridge. But before I venture my opinion on this project, I want to visit three different years in 20th century America. As you will see, the past is important to understanding my position on this project in the present but especially for the future.

The first year I want to examine is 1971. I began college that year. The apartment I rented was the first floor of a two family house in Queens, NY. My rent was $75 a month plus utilities. I had a full time job that paid $130 per week in a New York City hotel. The subway fare was 30 cents. The White Castle around the corner from my apartment charged 12 cents per slider. I ate there several times a week.

Now, it is 1953, the year of my birth. My mother told me the rent was $32.00 per month for our NYC apartment. The subway had just been raised from a dime to 15 cents. It was President Eisenhower’s first year in office, the Korean War ended and the minimum wage was 75 cents. Also 50% of American homes had a TV.

Lastly, let’s look at 1932 which is 83 years ago. The country was in the midst of the Great Depression. The U.S. GNP fell more that 13% and unemployment was 23.6%. Herbert Hoover was in the White House. You couldn’t buy a legal drink because Prohibition was still the law of the land. The New York City Subway was a nickel.

Do you think anyone in 1932 America could predict what our country would look like in 2015? In 1932 Stuart was 18 years old and Martin County was 7. There was radio, and talking pictures had been around for five years. Television, the internet and cellular phones were unknown. Hitler had yet to come to power in Germany. World War I was still referred to as the Great War. In 1932, forget about predicting what the world would look like in 2015, Americans couldn’t even see the world of 1943 and the inferno to come.

Understanding the above, if Stuart was negotiating a lease for Northpoint in 1932, what would the terms be? I would suspect vastly different than what they would be in 2015. But today Stuart is negotiating a lease for Northpoint that will run 83 years until 2098. Lease terms written for the Stuart of 2015 that will bind our children, grandchildren and in some cases great grandchildren. Will the terms and concept of this lease be relevant at the dawn of the 22nd century?

We are obligating the city of tomorrow with our actions today. We may have a legal right to do so, but we do not possess the moral right. There is just no possible way that this is good government. This action is done with a great deal of hubris and paternalism. I have other serious doubts and questions about this project. Even if I had no others, I could not in good conscience vote for this lease; which will bind the hands of future generations of Stuartians long after I and the present commission are gone.